Wednesday, October 28, 2020

A Diversity of Gifts (midweek message)

 


Fr. Tony’s Midweek Message

A Diversity of Gifts

October 28, 2020

 

“1I therefore, the prisoner in the Lord, beg you to lead a life worthy of the calling to which you have been called, 2with all humility and gentleness, with patience, bearing with one another in love, 3making every effort to maintain the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace. 4There is one body and one Spirit, just as you were called to the one hope of your calling, 5one Lord, one faith, one baptism, 6one God and Father of all, who is above all and through all and in all. 7But each of us was given grace according to the measure of Christ’s gift. 8Therefore it is said, ‘When he ascended on high he made captivity itself a captive; he gave gifts to his people.’…  11The gifts he gave were that some would be apostles, some prophets, some evangelists, some pastors and teachers, 12to equip the saints for the work of ministry, for building up the body of Christ, 13until all of us come to the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God, to maturity, to the measure of the full stature of Christ. 14We must no longer be children, tossed to and fro and blown about by every wind of doctrine, by people’s trickery, by their craftiness in deceitful scheming. 15But speaking the truth in love, we must grow up in every way into him who is the head, into Christ, 16from whom the whole body, joined and knitted together by every ligament with which it is equipped, as each part is working properly, promotes the body’s growth in building itself up in love.”  (Ephesians 4:1-16)

 

We often hear the bit “One Lord, One Faith, One Baptism, One God and Father of All” in this passage since it is repeated in the baptismal rite.  But we sometimes miss the larger point being made: God gave his people a variety of gifts, and in order to love and follow God, we need to honor and accept the diversity of gifts he saw fit to grant.  We need to accept that some people don’t have a particular gift that we love because it was the loving God who did not give it to them.  Rather, we need to honor them for the gifts God did give them. 

 

Such acceptance and gratitude is the heart of unity and shared life.  Without it, we are left prey to the vagaries of popular whim and the divisions of sectarian quirkiness.  With it, we grow into the fullness of Christ together, despite and because of our differences. 

 

Grace and Peace.

Fr. Tony+



Wednesday, October 21, 2020

Standing with Others (Mid-week)

 


Fr. Tony’s Mid-week Message
Standing with Others
October 21, 2020
 
One of the priestly blessings I use most often at the end of Eucharist is adapted from the Church of England’s Common Worship and is a summary of 1 Thessalonians 5:13-22:
 
“Go forth into the world in peace.  Be of good courage.  Render to no one evil for evil.  Strengthen the weak. Visit the sick.  Stand with the downtrodden.  Honor every person.  Love and serve God, rejoicing in the power of the Holy Spirit.  And the blessing of God Almighty, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit, be among with you and remain with you always.  Amen.”

Deacon Carol Howser once told me that she had found the words “stand with the down trodden” particularly helpful, since she had a bad week where it was clear that through her efforts she could not really solve any of the problems for people she was working with, and that the best she could manage was to “stand with” them. 
 
Sara Miles writes that the most important word in the Bible is not “God,” “Jesus,” or “Mercy,” but simply “with.”  Relationship—being with someone, not simply doing things for them—is at the heart of our Christian faith and life.  She describes the Holy Trinity as a perichoreisis, a dance of the three persons with each other, the Incarnation as God made fully human and present with us, and Pentecost as the Holy Spirit sent to be with us in the Church.  Christian service is not simply doing things for others.  It is being with them, in relationship with them:

“Doing for, as mission groups and lovers and parents know, is super-tempting: it’s easier and often feels safer than being fully with. Let me act on your behalf, doing something for you as if my being were somehow separate from yours. Let me hand you a sandwich at a sanctified distance. Let me solve your homework problems without getting entangled in your other problems. Let me send you some flowers to apologize when I’ve been snappish, without having a real conversation. Being with is riskier. If I wait and listen and show you what I’m really like, my life becomes implicated in yours: we are no longer separate. And I might get changed by our relationship.”

May we learn to content ourselves to stand with others, simply be with them, fully present, and come to share gladly what our being with them leads us to share. 

Peace and Grace, 
Fr. Tony+

(adapted and reposted from 2013)

Tuesday, October 20, 2020

Caesar's Coin (Proper 24A)

 


Caesar’s Coin

18 October 2020

Proper 24A

8 a.m. Said Mass on the Labyrinth; 10:00 alive-streamed from the Chancel

The Parish Church of Trinity Ashland (Oregon)

The Rev. Fr. Tony Hutchinson, SCP, Ph.D.

 

Exodus 33:12-23; Psalm 99; 1 Thessalonians 1:1-10; Matthew 22:15-22


God, take away our hearts of stone and give us hearts of flesh. Amen.

 

 

In today’s Gospel reading, people ask Jesus to endorse a tax revolt against the Roman Empire.  They ask this not because they seek such a revolt.  The Pharisees here believe that one can pay Roman taxes and still keep God’s Law.  The Herodians support the local royal family and are collaborators with the Roman occupiers.  Both have marked Jesus as an all too subtle threat to the system, and want to force his hand.

 

“Is it right to pay taxes to the Roman Emperor?” they innocently ask.  

 

Such taxes had led to riots in the past and that ultimately would lead to the destruction of the Jewish homeland in 70 C.E.    Payment of taxes to the Romans was seen not only as a sign of political enslavement, but also as an idolatrous act forbidden by God.

 

The scene in today’s Gospel takes place in one of the outer courtyards of the Jerusalem Temple during Passover week.  The city is crowded to commemorate God’s delivery of the Israelites from slavery in Egypt.  The risk of mob violence is great.   The previous day, Jesus staged high political theater by disrupting the flow of money in the Temple by driving out moneychangers.

 

Amid this tension, they ask him innocently, “Is it permitted to pay taxes to the Emperor?”  

If Jesus says “yes,” he marks himself as an Imperial tool, a quisling, and a disloyal Jew, fair game for the rage of the mob.  If he answers “no,” he commits treason and marks himself for Roman execution.

Jesus replies, “In what coin is the tax paid?  Can you show me one?” 

They produce a Roman denarius, the coin for a common laborer’s wage for a day.  It is a common enough in archeological digs from the period, bearing an image of Tiberius Caesar on its front, with the inscription, “Caesar Augustus Tiberius, son of the God Augustus”:  Son of God, despite the fact that Tiberius’ perversions against children and sick wickedness on his resort island of Capri were well known.   Jesus asks innocently, “Whose image is that?  And whose inscription?” 

Jesus has thus caught them in a trap.  They are in the Temple, in the same space that Jesus yesterday cleared of moneychangers. By producing a Roman coin in this spot, Jesus’ opponents show to all that they have carried a coin with an image—an blasphemous image with a clearly idolatrous inscription—into the sacred precincts.  Their sheepish reply shows they know they have been had, “It bears the Emperor’s image and his inscription.” 

Jesus replies, “Well then, if it’s to Caesar that this coin belongs, then give it back to him!”  And then he adds, slyly, “And what belongs to God, give to God.” 

Christians over the centuries have usually understood this saying of Jesus as defining two separate spheres: God’s workings versus earthly political activity, the Church versus the State.  In light of Romans 13’s admonition that everyone “be in subjection to the governing authorities. For there is no authority except from God and those which exist are established by God,” the advocates of two spheres say that since God set earthly rulers in their positions over us, we owe obedience to them as a duty to God.  By definition, the Christian is a citizen who abides by the law of the land.  It is only when the government requires us to do something forbidden by God that we obliged to resist.  Constantine, Luther, and ultimately the Nazis all said that this meant that the Church should be under the state’s control.  


But Jesus here is not intending two spheres at all.  Pre-Constantinian Father Tertullian points to Jesus’ words, “give back to God what is God’s” and asks, “What is it that has God’s image? Why, human beings, of course, since ‘God created human beings in his own image’ in Genesis 1.”  In other words, it is not a question of two spheres, but one alone: God’s. 

 

Jesus is not in favor of idolizing Caesar. But he is not in favor of revolting, for he knows that such things as this can be just as corrupted as the things they revolt against.   

“Go ahead and give Tiberius that coin, since it plainly belongs to him. But more importantly, we must pay back to God what is his!” 

 

He does not believe that you should get worked up over paying taxes, whether out of an outraged sense of political insult (a loss of “liberty”) or maintaining your ritual or moral purity (not committing “idolatry.”)  

 

If you are already up to your neck in swamp mud, you shouldn’t start going all sentimental about keeping your cheeks free of the filth. Jesus knows that we are living in occupied territory.  Not just Romans occupying Palestine, but spiritual Powers and Dominions, the evil systems that occupy God's good creation.  And Jesus says, do what you need to do to get by under such an occupation.  Pay the tax.  But don't let it fool you one bit.  Focus first on our obligation to return all that we are and have to God. 


My first career, as a U.S. diplomat, lasted 25 years. I had many years to think about the contrast between what works and gets you ahead in government and what Jesus taught.  Here are a few contrasts between Caesar’s coin and God’s.

Caesar’s coin is to do the expedient.    God’s is to do the right, do the beautiful.  

Caesar’s coin is to control.  God’s is to empower and to serve.

Caesar’s coin is what is in your group’s interest, whether nation, tribe, or party. God’s is what benefits those who need the most.

Caesar’s coin is achieving measurable goals and benchmarks.  God’s does not worry about results. 

Caesar’s coin is force and violence.  God’s is gentle love. 

Caesar’s coin is judgment and punishment, law and order.  God’s is grace, compassion, inclusion, and forgiveness. 

Caesar’s coin is reputation and public image.  God’s is true character and service.  

Caesar’s coin is making your point.  God’s is shutting up and listening. 

Caesar’s coin is taking credit by proper branding.  God’s is slight embarrassment at having to have been lucky enough to be there for a good thing, and a preference for anonymity.   

The world we live in is occupied territory.  All of us live under the spiritual Powers and Dominions, and as such, we are all in Caesar’s game, and have to pay in Caesar's coin.  In the degree that this is so, we play by Caesar’s rules.  But as Jesus said after his arrest, “those who live by the sword die by it.”  There is a much more important game afoot.  There are much, much more important issues that we should focus on.  

I pray that during this week, in meditation, reflection, and prayer, we all take note of the idols in our lives and then move to put them in their place.  Give back to Caesar what he owns.  But give to God what is God’s. 
 

In the name of Christ, Amen.

Wednesday, October 14, 2020

Persistence in a Stressed-out World (mid-week)

 


Fr. Tony’s Midweek Message

Persistence in a Stressed-out World

October 14, 2020

 

“But we have this treasure [of the Gospel] in pottery jars, easily broken, so that it may be made clear that this extraordinary power belongs to God and does not come from us.  We are afflicted in every way, but not crushed; perplexed, but not driven to despair;  persecuted, but not forsaken; struck down, but not destroyed;  always carrying in the body the death of Jesus, so that the life of Jesus may also be made visible in our bodies.” — 2 Cor 4:7-10

 

We are all feeling a bit beaten down.  I have heard from several parishioners that they are not sleeping well.  Some have told me they are deeply depressed.  This is the result from long, ongoing stress from the pandemic and public hygiene measures, the economic crash, the viciously divided election cycle with concerns about achieving a free and fair election whose results are peacefully respected, and the horror of the wildfires last month and the bad, smoky air that we breathe as we try to address the almost overwhelming need the Almeda fire kindled.    

 

Even achieving regular, ongoing tasks has become immeasurably harder:  shopping, getting a haircut, exercising—they all take longer and involve more preparation and recovery time.  In Church, updating and maintaining the technical setup for our services takes hours each week.  After initially getting the technology right, this has generally worked seamlessly.  But last Sunday, we had a short ISP-triggered break in our feed at the 10 a.m. service that totally shut down our mevo camera and mic, locking them so that I could not reboot.  The result was that for many of you, Sunday Mass ended after 17 minutes and only 3 minutes of homily.  Due to all sorts of little problems (an i-phone system upgrade, the need to restore all the links and preferences, and a required program upgrade for the camera/mic itself) it took me three full days of work before I could get the system working.  It is now up and running again and there should be no problems this week.  

 

Trying to fix a technical problem can be very frustrating.  But the needed way forward through it is to be persistent, and keep on doing the next right thing.  If that doesn’t work, reassess and then do the next next right thing.  Read the manuals, talk to tech support, and keep on trying.  Patience and intentionally relaxing the neck and hands, taut because of stress, helps get us through.  In the end, it works. 

 

I think this applies not just to technical fixes, but to getting through stressful hassles in general.  Be persistent.  Don’t give in and don’t give up.  Just do the next right thing. 

 

A priest friend of mine once told me of an unexpected conversation he had a few years ago at a gas station in rural North Carolina.  He handed the attendant his credit card, which listed his name prefaced with “the Rev.” The attendant paused, stared at it, looked up, and asked, “Are you some kind of a preacher?” My friend said, “Yes, I am an Episcopal priest.” The attendant paused and said, “I’m an agnostic. I think we agnostics and you Episcopalians are closer than anybody.” My friend  replied, “I think you might be right,” and then asked, “How did you become an agnostic?” The attendant said, rather sadly, “Out of disillusionment with life. But, I do read a lot about religion.”  They talked about books on spirituality, and began a long-distance exchange of books and articles.  When my friend visited there next, the attendant no longer worked at the station:  he had gone to seminary, been ordained, and was a minister in the nearby town.  “Unexpected sharing can go in unexpected, but great, directions,” was my friend’s moral of the story. 

 

We Episcopalians may indeed be very close to agnostics:  we remain open to things beyond our ken, unwilling to claim to know things that remained cloaked in uncertainty.  We are sensitive enough that on occasion we become disillusioned with life.  And we know that faith is more an orientation of the heart and on-going practice than it is adherence to a set of dogmas.  

 

But here’s the thing:  it is at those very moments when we are most beaten down that we need to persist, and always seek to take the next required step, to do the next right thing.     A regular, daily practice of prayer helps us get through the rough bits.  And if we persist, in the end, all will be well. 

 

Grace and peace. 

Fr. Tony+

Sunday, October 11, 2020

The Parable of the Invitation (Proper 23A)

 


The Parable of the Invitation

11 October 2020: 8 a.m. Said Mass on the Labyrinth;

10 a.m. Said Mass with Cantors live-streamed from the Chancel

Proper 23A

The Rev. Fr. Tony Hutchinson, SCP, Ph.D.

Parish of Trinity, Ashland (Oregon)

8:00 am said; 10 am sung Mass

Isaiah 25:1-9 Psalm 23 Philippians 4:1-9 Matthew 22:1-14

 

God, give us hearts to feel and love. 

Take away our hearts of stone and give us hearts of flesh. Amen. 

 

What in the world was that Gospel reading about?  If a king invites a whole lot of people to a party and he’s so scary that everyone finds a polite excuse to get out of it, there’s something wrong with that king.  And if you dragoon me in from the street as a party stuffer for all the No RSVPs you have received, only to humiliate and shame me for not wearing just the right clothes, and then throw me out, there’s something the matter with you.  

 

Matthew’s Jesus starts it with “the kingdom of heaven is like….”  But remember that this isn’t saying that king is somehow God.  The phrase means something more like “Let me tell you a story that will help you see how God rules over us.”   

 

The king here is clearly a psycho, totally self-absorbed and narcissistic.  This is how Nero, Caligula, or some petty but nasty dictator in a banana republic throws parties.  By seeing how bad such “hospitality” is, we see maybe what God’s invitations are like by contrast.  

 

Matthew was written just after Vespasian destroyed the Jewish homeland and its Temple.  The Gospel writer suffers from serious post-traumatic stress syndrome.  And he is the only Gospel that pictures Jesus teaching clearly “from John the Baptist until now, the Kingdom of Heaven has been suffering violence and the violent continue to take it by force” (Matthew 11:12).

 

Once again, Matthew has taken a parable from Jesus and added all sorts of details to turn it into an allegory, changing its meaning in the process.  Like last week, the earlier form of the parable is preserved in the Gospel of Luke and the non-canonical Gospel of Thomas.

 

It originally ran this way:

 

A rich man gave a great dinner to which he invited many guests. When all was ready, he sent his servant to summon the guests. But one by one, they all gave excuses for not coming. Hearing this, the rich man commanded his servant, ‘Go out quickly into the streets and alleys and bring in anyone you find. I want my great hall to be filled for the banquet.’


Most of Jesus’ audience knew that a great banquet was a big scriptural image for God’s future saving act.  Even though many passages said, like today’s Isaiah reading, that this banquet would be for all nations (Isaiah 25:7), many teachers said that it would be an exclusive event limited to God’s people only. 

 

Jesus replied to such a stingy image of God with parables. He points to the weather and says that God gives his rain and sunshine to both good and bad people alike (Matt. 5:45).   He points to families and notes that when children ask for bread to eat, parents do not give them stones, or when they ask for an egg to eat, do not give them a scorpion, or when a fish, not a snake. “If even average parents try to give their children good things, how much more generous will God be?” (Matt. 7:9-10; Luke 11:11-13)

And Jesus’ actions matched his words. He regularly ate and drank with people declared contagiously unclean by his religion.   He welcomed them.   He tells people to accept God’s invitation without fear or anxiety.  “Don’t worry about how you’re clothed,” he says, “the wild flowers are prettier than King Solomon all decked out, without any worries at all.”  When he sends the apostles out, he tells them to just take one change of clothes and no more, to accept people’s hospitality, not be picky about their food, and eat whatever their hosts give them.

 

He asks Martha, driven to distraction about getting every little detail of her dinner for Jesus just right, whether she might relax a little, and focus on the one thing that will give her joy, like her sister Mary.   I heard this text preached this weak by Archbishop Melissa Skelton at the annual convocation of my religious order.  She said, 

 

“We are all worried to distraction about getting things right: the technical live-stream feeds and zoom meetings, all the safety and hygiene rules for reengaging our buildings.  These are things we should worry about, but not to distraction.  If it had been me, I would not have asked Jesus, like Martha, to make my sister carry her weight in the worry game.  I would have asked Jesus to just fix it.  But that is not the savior we are given.  He is there with us in our sorrows, fear, and worries, but we must not expect him to fix things at our beck and call.  We can only, like Mary, look at him, listen to him, and be strengthened by his intentions and presence.”    


Jesus’ original parable tells the story of the host forced by RSVP “regrets” to drag in people from off the street to say God’s banquet is open to all.  It’s all about grace.  But Matthew adds all the nasty details about a psychopathic king and invitees scared to death of getting things wrong, and that poor guy without proper wedding clothes thrown out into the street bound hand and foot.  He is trying to explain that no matter how gracious God’s invitation, we need to be attentive and intentional in accepting it.  Matthew’s image of having proper clothes for the wedding becomes in the Gospel of Thomas a symbol of whether we have actually truly accepted God’s gift. 

 

At Caesar’s party, where all is fear and stress, if anyone is like that guy thrown out it is Jesus himself.   Jesus was taken outside the city wall and nailed to a cross because he just was not up to snuff when it came for giving proper respect to Rome. 

 

God is a kind and loving host, and invites us all.  There is no need for stress or anxiety.  The good news in this is that God’s invitation is not like Caesar’s.  God is not a psycho killer.  We need not fear. 

 

But in order to accept God’s invitation, we have to be open to receive it. St. Augustine says, ‘God gives where He finds open hands.’ You can't receive the gift if your hands are already full, or are clenched tight.

In yet another parable, Jesus compares God’s kingdom to a narrow path and a tight gate, which at any given time only a few can manage to squeeze through (Matt 7:13-14). This is because in order to get through such a tight fit, people have to be willing to abandon all the baggage they are carrying, whether riches, resentments, self-will, sins, or even what appears to be good things if they are getting in the way. 

 

What does accepting grace, freely offered, look like in practical terms? 

It looks like me admitting that I am helpless and hopeless. It sounds like the sincere phrase “I am sorry and I humbly repent.” It feels like Martin Luther’s heartfelt cry, “I am yours Lord, save me.”  

I myself have known God’s grace.   All was hopeless and helpless, through my own “thoughtlessness, weakness, through my own deliberate fault.”   I found that I had to accept my own powerlessness and turn it all over to God. And keep doing that, each day.  Gradually, steadily, God worked wonderful changes. I am still far from what God wants. But I live each day in gratitude.

I know that many of you have had similar experiences. You have told me your stories.   We need to continue in faith and gratitude, and share the invitation to the party through our actions and words.

If you have not had such an experience, then please listen to this call to God’s banquet, you random passerby on the street, and come it to the party.   The tickets are free. But they are not cheap. Once it the door and settled at the table, we must continue to respond to Jesus’ beckoning call.  This means amending our ways, making up as far as it is possible for our misdoings.  It means trying to be our best selves, being a bit better today than yesterday, this year than last. 

 

The banquet is priceless, the bread the finest, and the wine, a vintage that makes our hearts gladder than any other. Come to the banquet, don’t be afraid.  And, without sinking into fear or anxiety, let’s try to dress appropriately.

 

In the name of Christ, Amen.

Wednesday, October 7, 2020

Fear and Trembling (Mid-week Message)


 

Fear and Trembling

Fr. Tony’s Midweek Message

October 6, 2020

 

“So then, my beloved, obedient as you have always been, not only when I am present but all the more now when I am absent, work out your salvation with fear and trembling” (Philippians 2:12).

 

Do not be afraid; just have faith.” Mark 5:36

 

Jesus says “Do not be afraid” many times in the Gospel.  In fact, the phrase frames his ministry, life, and death: the angel Gabriel says it to the Blessed Virgin at the Annunciation and the angel on Easter morning says it to the women who come to Jesus’ tomb.  So you would think that anyone who says, “Don’t be afraid” is only echoing what Jesus taught. 

 

But that is both a foolish and unhealthy approach.  Jesus also said, “be wise as snakes and harmless as doves.”    When he predicted his death and suffering, his disciples said, “don’t worry.”  Jesus replied, “Don’t tempt me, Satan.”  He called on them (and calls on us) to pick up a cross and follow him in his sufferings.  This is because, as the prayer book Holy Week collect says, the way of the cross is ultimately the way of life and light. 

 

The Lord never promised us that we never would suffer pain or fearful things, but promised that he would always be with us in our suffering.  And he advised us to be prudent and wise.  We must do our bit with as many smarts as we can muster, but then trust in God.  In medical issues, that means following doctors’ and public health authorities’ advice in addition to praying and trusting God.   In Church in the era of Covid-19, it means following state and county guidelines for reopening, and making sure we keep the Church as safe as we can.  In an era of climate change and wildfires, it means keeping our homes’ grounds clear of flammable items and always having an emergency bag ready to take with us in case of evacuation, and working for policy change to turn back the degradation of the environment. 

 

Note that the scripture tells us to “work out our salvation” with “fear and trembling.”  This does not mean timidly or overly cautious; it does not mean distrusting and being terrified of God.  It means attending to real risks and dangers within the context of trusting God.   And it is work.   Attending to real risks must of necessity be rooted in informed attentiveness to the facts and science. 

 

Grace and peace. 

Fr. Tony+

Sunday, October 4, 2020

Desperate Farmers (Proper 22A)

 


Desperate Farmers

(Proper 22A)

8:00 a.m. Said Mass on the Labyrinth,

10:00 a.m. Said Mass with cantors live-streamed from the chancel

4 October 2020

Parish Church of Trinity Ashland (Oregon)
Isaiah 5:1-7 Psalm 80: 7-14 Philippians 3:4b-14 Matthew 21:33-46

God, give us hearts to feel and love,
take away our hearts of stone and give us hearts of flesh. Amen.

 

We have seen in the last few weeks several parables of Jesus that have been re-interpreted by Matthew’s Gospel:  Matthew regularly takes a parable that has a single point and turns it into an allegory, a story with several points of comparison.  Last week, it was the parable of the two sons, the big talker and the big doer (Matt. 21:23-32).  Jesus meant this as a simple contrast between saying and not doing on the one hand and not saying but just doing on the other; Matthew turned this into an allegory about the religiously orthodox (Pharisees and scribes) and repentant notorious sinners (tax-collectors and sex-workers).   The week before that, it was the parable of the day laborers (Matt. 20:1-16), which Matthew understood as an allegory about the grateful ones come lately to faith and the resentful ones who have been here a long time.  On Jesus’ lips it was a critique of the unfairness of the marketplace and the careless ways of the wealthy, where an act of kindness triggers anger by those not favored, due to the unfairness of the larger system.  The week before that, it was the parable of the unmerciful servant (Matt. 18:22-35).  Again, what for Jesus had been an edgy critique of the careless rich, great and small, had become for Matthew an allegory about the need for us to forgive others if we expect to be forgiven ourselves by God. 

 

 


 

The images in today’s readings, the parable of the vineyard in Isaiah, and the parable of the wicked tenants in Matthew, both use the rich images of viniculture to talk about our relationship with God: we must produce or risk being discarded. That much is obvious from the Lectionary’s juxtaposition of these two passages. 

 

But here, once again, Matthew has reframed and reinterpreted a parable of Jesus.   When you compare it with how it is preserved in Luke and in the Gospel of Thomas, you see what Matthew has added:  all the little details that tell us to see in the parable a complex allegory: the direct allusion to the parable of the vineyard in Isaiah, the complex narrative about different slaves being sent and some getting killed and others just beaten, or the detail of the murdered son’s body being tossed out outside vineyard.  Even the concluding question, “what do you think that landowner is going to do to those tenants?” is missing in the original form. 

Matthew, writing after the Roman army’s destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem in 70 C.E., sees Jesus’s parable as an explanation of that earth-shattering event: God clears the vineyard by destroying the Temple and filling its place with the Church.  In this supercessionist understanding of the parable, the Landlord is God; the tenants, the people of Israel; the agents sent and then abused, the prophets; and the “only son, the heir,” Jesus Christ.  The idea is that God’s chosen people over the centuries rejected the prophets, and abused and killed some, and finally rejected Jesus, killed outside the city wall.

 

As much sense as it would have made to Matthew, this understanding of the parable is deeply problematic.  St. Paul never believed that God had rejected his people, or had changed his deal with them, only that God had included Gentiles in the scope of grace and election.   And the violent and dark history of Christian anti-Semitism, with pogroms and massacres regularly happening on Good Friday over the centuries, demands that we eschew supercessionism or any version of the blood libel blaming “the Jews” for deicide.   Such ideas, though part of scripture, should be recognized as an unholy foray of the mind, just like the Psalmist’s murderous prayers that his enemies’ babies’ brains be smashed against the wall. 

The story as originally told by Jesus is a shocking tale of how desperate tenant farmers in first century Palestine had become.   Its original point was to contrast how wrong the world was in this system of things with how things might be if God’s reign were here in full power.  The opening line, “the kingdom of heaven is like,” is better translated as “let me tell you a story about what God’s kingdom is, and what it isn’t.” 

Just look at the landowner here:  he is not sending those servants out of any concern for the tenant farmers.  He is sending them, probably with strong-armed goons, to pick up the latest installment of squeeze.  The farmers, desperate, resort to strong-arm tactics to defend themselves, not once, but twice. 

Think about how such a parable would have been heard by the crowds of peasants and day laborers following Jesus.    He starts the story of an absentee landowner.  He sends his henchman from the city to the farm to get the produce for this season.  The farmers have had enough!  They rise up and send the goon packing!  I can imagine that Jesus’ audience here probably cheered.   The landowner sends another, bigger, goon with more “motivation” to come back with the goods.  But again, the poor tenants send him away empty handed!   The crowd at this point is going wild at this story where things are finally going as they ought to!  But then the landowner sends his own son—an only child—to make sure the tenants haven’t been secretly paying kickbacks to the goons to get them to go back empty-handed.   The crowd becomes silent in anticipation of how this interesting story will end.   But the tenants, seeing the son, misunderstand what’s going on.  They think that the landowner has died, and that the son is making an inspection tour to make sure his inheritance is in order.  And so they kill him, thinking that they will get squatters’ rights on unclaimed property if the son himself has not left a will.   The crowd is in doubt now; they don’t know who to side with.  They see the twist in the story, the unexpected fact that the Landowner is not dead.  And they know what he is going to do at the murder of his son by these lawless tenants.  He will wreak a terrible vengeance, slaughtering the farmers and their families, and replacing them with docile, productive ones so he can go back to city to enjoy the high life off the proceeds of the farm. 

I doubt that there was any cheering now.   The poor people in the audience have just heard a story that reminds them of how they simply must mind their own business and play along with the oppressors lest things go totally wrong.  The rich in the audience, the religious leaders, the lawyers, know that Jesus has just blasted the system of oppression that has made them wealthy and powerful.  No one cheers, but everyone wonders at the story. 

This story should make us wonder as well.  Most of the turmoil in our nation in recent months stems from a sense of grievance of those whose lives and livelihoods are at risk due to the caste system of color in the U.S.   This has been expressed generally peacefully, but on occasion has broken into violence reflecting the violence implicit in the system.  How much of the good life we enjoy comes from work of others, and that unfairly?  How much is gained by the exploitation of others and the violation of an increasingly fragile natural environment?  How is it possible to address unjust systems of power and wealth?  Is it right to do so, and if so, what means are just and right to do so?   The Landowner and the tenants in this story have clear ideas of honor, fairness, and law.  I wonder how our ideas of such things fare in such a world as seen in Jesus’ story.    This week, I invite us to let this story work in us, and make us wonder a whole lot.  

In the name of Christ, Amen